[gbcdoj]

I have read The Mass of the Roman Rite. He doesn't call the Pius V Missal a "new rite", and yes, I know all about the removal of the Marian tropes to the Gloria, etc. That doesn't make it "new".

[bornacatholic]

Reread it. Jungmann clearly illsutrates it is a new rite that replaced other rites already existing- except those existing for 200 years

[bornacatholic]

Catholic Encyclopedia "1570. St. Pius V published a Bull on the occasion, still printed at the beginning of the Missal, in which he enjoined that all dioceses and religious orders of the Latin Rite should use the new revision and no other, excepting only such bodies as could prove a prescription of two hundred years.

*The new revision, new rite, except for the 200 y.o. rites, replaced what, if not other Rites? If something is new, does it qualify as new?