[OldFriend]

Eliot is just plain good people and that's what endeared him to so many folks.

I still can't figure out how Mandisa was voted off.

[misterrob]

Because she wore a bad outfit and doesn't have a body like Pickler of McPhee.

She would have been formidable in the final 4!!! I hope she and Elliott do a song together on the tour.

[floridaobserver]

Mandisa wore a hideous jean outfit on her last show . . she didn't look like an Idol at all, not with her rear caboose in tight jeans, anyway.

She should have sung Stand By Your Man on Country Night and she would have stayed for several more rounds!

[over3Owithabrain]

I still can't figure out how Mandisa was voted off.

Ummm, how can I put this delicately - er, GIANT ASS


-this is the smokey backroom, isn't it :)