My thoughts off the top of my head was that Polarik has been in contact with many people and the general consensus [of those people] is that is is not authentic. I do not think he has made any type of judgement. As detailed as he is I would have been shocked if he made a judgement one way or another in such a short period of time.
I think I am agreeing with what you said.. That’s the one thing about these long threads....
Yes, he made those comments prematurely and even expressed some frustration because he didn’t have the time personally to do extensive examination on the document and was going on things that were commented on in the beginning.
At first glance, you can assume it’s fake because of some things, but after a more in depth look those things make a little more sense.