I totally agree.
Guillianni as a social liberal may "sell" in NYC, but he'll fail miserably in the heartland of America.
Exactly. That's why he'd make a good Gov of NY, or better yet a Senator after ousting Hillary in 2 yrs. His unacceptability to social conservatives would be no different than Dem refusal to accept Sen Nelson of Nebraska or Bayh of Indiana.
Giuliani's problem is that he isn't even a social moderate, as often labeled by the press, but instead is a bonafide liberal on social and cultural issues.