It’s not up to FR to come to a consensus. An honest person reading the links to the founders letters essays, etc and the early court cases has no room for confusion.
The Cornell law group knew that which is why they tried to push through legislation to establish a new definition and allow Obama to run without controversy. Cornell failed and when Obama did run the indolence and cupidity of the GOP-e and the aggressive nature of the left allowed the issue to be pushed aside and not reported on.
Of course legally speaking a consensus on Free Republic is meaningless.
But considering the number of responses we get whenever the issue of Natural Born citizenship is discussed on Free Republic, there were many many widely Divergent opinions.