Can Pixar even make a Dud? Is it even possible for them?
Even the one sequel Pixar did, Toy Story 2, ended up being better than the first one.
It happens with every Pixar movie, when I saw the trailer for “Nemo,” I thought, how can a movie about fish be interesting. Ditto with the Incredibles and Cars. I’ve learned my lesson not to underestimate Pixar.
Well, I didn't like Cars, so perhaps I'm not the person to ask. Still, their output has been amazing.
One of the things I so admire about Pixar's team is their love of story. Put the project in the hands of good people, and get out of their way without ego - telling a good story is the first priority.
And sure enough, when John Lassetar took over Disney animation, the first thing he did was stop the endless stream of mediocre direct-to-video sequels. Good for him.