Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix (Spoiler Alert!!)

07/11/07 | Dianna

[schwing_wifey]

But at least I saw something like it on Filch’s face when he ate the “gift” from the twins.... heavens I loved the results of their product developments.... I was really hoping they’d give puking pastiles to Umbridge...

BTW... that actress was quite wonderful...she did an excellent rendition of the character...

;D

[EmilyGeiger]

I still haven’t got to see the movie. :( But I did hear that Cho was the sneak. Did she have bad acne like the book? :)

[EmilyGeiger]

At least she was spared the pimple curse from Hermione. Oops, should have read further down . :)

[js1138]

That's when I realized I didn't remember Umbridge saying she was the one who sent the dementors. Does anyone remember movie Umbridge revealing that little bit of info?

For those who can read between the lines, her guilt is strongly implied during the trial.

At the end, there is a newspaper headline announcing an investigation of her.

Making this explicit in the movie would drag down the main plotline.

[Dianna]

Does anyone remember movie Umbridge revealing that little bit of info? If she did my husband and I completely missed it.

Does she say that in the movie?

I had assumed the dementors were working for Voldemort, not sent by anyone at the Ministry.

[Dianna]

Malfoy asked for a room where he wouldn’t be disturbed.

But Trelawney got in.

[null and void]

I had assumed the dementors were working for Voldemort, not sent by anyone at the Ministry.

Nope, in the book, Umbridge brags that she sent the dementors when no one else in the Ministry was capable of decisive action.

[Dianna]

And I don’t think I could love Neville more. I loved when he yelled at Bellatrix, “Better, now that they’re about to be avenged!” I’m really, really hoping that we see much more Neville Deathly Hallows.

I think we will see more of Neville. There has been so much made of the fact of him not being very talented, yet his parents were supposed to be brilliant.

I think he might surprise us.

[null and void]

But Trelawney got in.

Trelawney wasn't trying to disturb Malfoy.

[Dianna]

Nope, in the book, Umbridge brags that she sent the dementors when no one else in the Ministry was capable of decisive action.

I completely missed that!! And I've read the books several times.

[Dianna]

Does Snape die?

I'd like to see Snape die by saving Harry and then everyone finds out he's really been a good guy all along.

It's not that I like Snape so much (although he's a great character!), but I'd HATE for Dumbledore to have made such a mistake.

[Dianna]

Trelawney wasn't trying to disturb Malfoy.

Good point!

[null and void]

IIRC, (and the kids have the books, I’ve got the tapes) it was when they were captured in her office, shortly before the was trying to work herself up to applying the Cruciatus curse on Harry.

Maybe I can find it on the tape...

[Dianna]

IIRC, (and the kids have the books, I’ve got the tapes) it was when they were captured in her office, shortly before the was trying to work herself up to applying the Cruciatus curse on Harry.

I've got the book handy, I'll check it out. Thanks!

[null and void]

Maybe I can find it on the tape...

On second thought, it can wait.

[Dianna]

On second thought, it can wait.

LOL! If anyone else missed it, it's at the top of page 747. I can't believe I missed that!

[null and void]

It certainly illuminates her character, doesn’t it?

[EmilyGeiger]

Malfoy asked for a room where he wouldn’t be disturbed.
But Trelawney got in.

---

Actually Malfoy asked for a room to hide something in and so did Trelawney. That’s how she got in. Harry also asked to have a room to hide something in(his potions book). I think he was given the exact same room and didn’t realize it.I’m basing this on the description of the items in the room.

[EmilyGeiger]

She said it when she captured Harry and his friends using her fireplace the second time. Right before she tries to use the unforgiveable curse on him.

[EmilyGeiger]

It was the same room, on page 526 it talks about him passing the vanishing cabinet when he is trying to hide his book. I think when he goes back for the book he’ll see it and realize what happened.