You seem to base your entire presence here on your perspective of your Christianity, e.g., Christians do this or Christians don’t do that. I would therefore find it instructive to know what your definition of a Christian is, and just whom you would admit to the faith under your definition.
Your answer, please.
I can’t answer your question unless I know what you mean by *Catholic* and what you mean by *Christian*.
It’s intellectually dishonest to demand an answer to a question and expect me to provide the definitions of the words you are using. If you want a clear, precise answer, you must be clear and precise about the meanings of the terms you are using.
Since you are asking the question, it is up to you to provide the definitions.
That’s not an answer to the questions I asked, so I’ll repost them again....
BW: Are Catholics Christian? Yes or no.
mm: What’s it to you?
Why is that such an issue for you that you have to harp on it?
Why are you trying to cause such contention between denominations?
The only reasonable conclusion that someone can come to about your constant questioning of it when its not relevant to the discussion is that you are trying to cause sectarian division. Why are you doing that?
And I say that as a Christian.