Whole word reading does work. I taught both of my kids that way and they were well above all of their classmates from day one. The problem with whole word reading is that teachers either do it wrong or they don't have enough time as it is a very time consuming process and advances vary from child to child. It isn't one size fits all.
And as far as the amphetamine or methylphenidate stimulant drugs being used on children...somebody lost their damn mind!
Having said that, much of your "2)" is so absurd I'm not even going to bother replying. You'll probably take it the wrong way and you'll be just one more "hurt" member. However, if you really want me to chime in I will.
BTW, my "whole word" daughter wound up being her class valedictorian. My son did well too, though not as well as her.
Garbage.
Whole word does not work.
I have to tutor kids who get tossed away from the system, and the best part of my day is when they realise they are not stupid.
I teach phonics. I show them how words and sounds are connected with one another, something you think would be taught in elementary, but it is not taught. Then the kid struggles and thinks that he’s stupid and takes that chip on his shoulder through life.
Then the kid flunks out and gets sent to me.
“BS! The first word I read was from a sign in a commercial! “
You’re cracking me up. I was having an argument with the wife, with me saying junior could read, and she saying he can’t (he was 3). So I pointed to a McDonald’s sign, and he read it perfectly. She didn’t buy it. LOL.