Posted on 04/06/2015 4:37:53 PM PDT by 9thLife
A long, long time ago - to borrow the words of the song - Don McLean sat down to write the first lines of an epic. First released in 1971, American Pie is a classic that an entire generation memorised line by line, verse by verse.
Fans around the world have argued over the true meaning of one of the most enigmatic songs in pop history. Faced with all the speculation, McLean's own response is defiantly down-to-earth: when people ask him what it means, he likes to reply, "It means I never have to work again."
American Pie, famously covered by Madonna in 2000, remains a highlight of McLean's shows and his admirers will have a chance to hear it again when he starts a new UK tour next month. This Tuesday, meanwhile, sees a new chapter in the song's history when the original manuscript goes up for auction at Christie's in New York. Experts believe it could fetch as much as £1million.
Already a wealthy man thanks to the royalties, McLean seems matterof-fact about the prospect of his most famous work going under the hammer. In his own mind, at least, it has already passed out of his own hands to become public property.
Hidden away in a box in his home, the lyrics had lain almost forgotten for years. The soft-spoken singer finally decided to put them up for sale after he was contacted about the possibility of selling other memorabilia. After decades of touring and recording, it was time to take stock.
As he explains: "It occurred to me that there was some interest in the scratch work for a lot of the songs I had written. You know, I am going to be 70-years old this year, and my wife and children do not seem to have the knack of knowing when to sell something and when not to, so I said I had better do it for them.
It came out in pieces. It wasn't something I was figuring out Don McLean "Probably a year or two from now I will also sell a lot of my guitars and the clothes I wore on album covers."
Referring to the endless debate about the song's underlying meaning - its starting point was the singer's teenage memories of the death of Buddy Holly - McLean thinks anyone looking for revelations about "the day the music died" is likely to end up being disappointed.
"When the chance comes to get hold of the catalogue and look at some of the pages, you will see that it didn't come out that way," he explains.
"It came out in pieces. It wasn't something where I was figuring out who was going to be this and what was going to be that. I never did get involved in talking about it that way because that's not how it was written. People will see a song that's not a parlour game, but a song that went in a lot of different directions as I was trying to capture a dream. That's what I was trying to do."
We may like to think that all great tunes are written in a sudden eureka moment of inspiration, but McLean describes a very different process: "The first part - the "long, long time ago" part - came immediately. And then a little later I had the chorus, and I wanted it to be a fast song.
"Then I stopped thinking about it for a couple of months, because I couldn't figure out what to do, whether to go in an entirely different direction. A lot of that is reflected in the manuscript."
McLean's own journey into the music business was not exactly straightforward either. Raised in a conventional middle-class home in a well-to-do part of New York state, he knew that his father hoped that he would follow him down the safe and respectable path of office administration. Passionate about folk music - singing had originally helped him cope with childhood asthma - McLean hankered after a career as a performer instead.
When his first sorties seemed to lead nowhere he opted to study for a business degree at night school.
"I basically did it for my father, who had passed away a couple of years before," he recalls. "After I finished I thought 'Well I did it, Dad. Now I'm going to do what I wanna do'. I found I had a bit of an aptitude.
"A lot of the McLeans ran offices. My father did, my uncle did. I didn't want any part of working in an office, but I guess it was in my blood. After I finished studying I never looked back, but I did find it a lot of use for reading a contract."
Later, he was even offered a business scholarship at Columbia University in New York, but chose to stick to singing in the city's coffee houses. Rejected by countless labels, his first album was released in 1970. One year later American Pie changed everything.
McLean is far from a one-hit wonder - aside from Vincent, his melancholy portrait of Van Gogh, he also wrote And I Love You So, a ballad covered by crooner Perry Como. But it is American Pie that has defined his career. For some artists, the song might easily have become a millstone.
Don McLean in 1971 and the lyrics from the hit song he's sellingALAMY/CHRISTIES Don McLean in 1971 and the lyrics from the hit song he's selling McLean insists that was not the case: "There was never a time when I didn't sing it," he says. "I don't go to the theatre with the idea of disappointing the audience."
After what he tersely describes as "a bad marriage" early in his career and a long spell of footloose bachelorhood, he found domestic contentment relatively late in life. Since 1987 he has been married to Patrisha, a photographer, writer and mother of his two grown-up children, daughter Jackie and son Wyatt. Home is a spectacular lakeside estate in Maine where the couple focus much of their energy on growing roses. "It's 175 acres. Compared to places in Ireland and England it's not much," he says modestly. "I have quite a lot of fun fixing these places up."
THAT element of domestic tranquillity is reflected in the title of his forthcoming album Botanical Gardens. If he still seems resentful that some of the critics who championed him early on turned against him after the success of American Pie, he has come to terms with the fact that the song represented the high-water mark of his career. Throughout it all, he has remained busy, writing and recording. He even played Glastonbury in 2011.
Inevitably, though, the spotlight shifted away over time. After all, who could ever top that hit? "I had about as much fame around the world as I could handle," he says. "And I still have about as much fame as I can handle. I really was not a person who was seeking enormous popularity, so I wasn't heartbroken that my career might have been limited. I was already much more wealthy than my father had been. I had a fortune. As the years went on, more things happened and people realised, you know, that I was here to stay.
"What is it now, 46, 48 years that I've been around, selling out theatres and festivals and so on? I wasn't equipped to sustain that kind of popularity over a long period. I wasn't very comfortable with it."
• Don McLean's tour starts in York on May 15. For more information visit don-mclean.com
And Einstein did his best work in his 20's when he was an office clerk.
Not too many Grandma Moses's out there. For most of us, we do our best work early. Thank goodness for wisdom to fill void.
IIRC, “American Pie” recently overtook Righteous Bros “Unchained Melody” as the #1 hit in some polls.
The thing I remember liking about McLean from back then was that when the song was at its peak, he chose that New Year’s Eve, which used to be an ENORMOUS entertainment night, to perform at a small Upstate NY club where he’d been playing for years, in appreciation for their hiring him when no one else would.
I hate click bait.
But someone left the xake out, in the rain, all the sweet green icing, pouring down.
More than 40 years later and that tune does not register as worthy of rental. I remember it well, but have Papa Was a Rolling Stone in my library instead.
I assume that would be the Caffè Lena in Saratoga Springs.
Thanks Moonman,
Great background on the songs.
Typical of what passes for journalism these days... just designed to get you to stop on the web page as long as possible so a flock of pop up adds can assault your senses and they can get your IP address and plant some junk on your computer.
I was a teenager when it came out and got so sick of hearing this song play over and over on the radio. They just ran it into the ground. Hate the song to this day.
Ogawd and they say "American Pie" is obnoxious.
His peak was probably 68-70, "Hey Jude" through "Let it Be." But I can't listen to Beatles pre-Sgt. Pepper, except for "Hey Bulldog."
I really like his '70s music, from "Maybe I'm Amazed" through about 1976. "Live and Let Die" and "Band on the Run" rank up there with his best singles with the Beatles.
My only knock against the Beatles and McCartney solo is their nonsense lyrics.
15 or 20 years ago McClean was on CBS FM with the DJ explaining the song line by line. I came in at the end and was sorry to have missed it. Still don’t know what half of it is about.
Might be on youtube somewhere.
Those bands don’t get radio airplay, they don’t get Rolling Stone/Spin/Mojo etc profiles, they don’t get “out” of the small club circuit. They may get album reviews but they don’t make the cut when it comes to being written about. They are excluded.
20 years on they remain ‘independent also rans’. And the local bands usually hang it up in 2-8 years. Some last 20 years but they still rarely get to open at the bigger venues for the touring acts.
It doesn’t fit the Bill Graham business model.
Billy Joel did an even simpler minded ‘free associations’ song: “We Didn’t Start The Fire”
“JFK. Blown away. What else do I have to say?!!!”
And those bands ‘growing through the ranks’ may get to play Letterman or Conan but they don’t get to sit on the bench for a hello or interview and those songs don’t make it to radio (for a single spin, let alone rotation).
Brand New Key stands out in my memory.
-PJ
“Castles in the Air is his real gem.”
Concur, and I’m glad you brought that up. It predated American Pie, and that’s when I started listening to McLean.
OK, it’s certainly an indicator of its time, of the “back to the earth” movement and rejection of modernity. But still, a good tune and great example of McLean’s talent.
Until I read your post, I thought the phrase was "the court kept practice in the park."
“Brand New Key stands out in my memory.”
I used to just hate that song. It took decades to realize how brilliant it is, in a tongue in cheek sort of way.
Anyone who’s been stalked by a girl who’s a bit off mentally will certainly appreciate it.
An old, wise friend once observed “Never sleep with anyone crazier that you are.”
Good advice.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.