RC, if you are expecting me to kowtow to those case examples, it’s not going to happen. Everyone with my opinion believes that case to be badly decided.
Which is why I used the dissent..!
There is affirmation in dicta and somewhat related case law for both sides of this and that goes all the way back to the founding and the insertion of the term, natural born.
Unfortunately for you, the dissenting opinion is irrelevant. The assenting opinion is clear and our country has evolved around that opinion for over 100 years. there’s no going back now.