Should be easy enough to fact check.
Good point. I'd not waste a lot of time canvassing the country for someone who remembers taking the LSAT with Hillary, but it would be interesting to know if she's ever told this story before.
There is always the possibility that some hyper-aggressive idiot started trash talking-- we'are talking aspiring lawyers here -- and a couple of sidekick idiots chimed in. It's possible Hillary started something with an ill-considered remark. People have been known to do stupid things. The story doesn't ring true, but stranger things have happened.
That said, it's a colorful enough story that Hillary would certainly have used it from time to time over the years. Has she ever told it before? One of her courtiers coming forward now with a cover story, and saying Hillary shared it with them 25 years ago, isn't going to count. The tale needs to have been in print before now to have any credibility at all.