These lists tend to be rather arbitrary.
I do like the “cheapest month to visit” feature. Race Point in January is freezing cold and Provincetown if it’s like other summer beach towns in Massachusetts will be dead, dead, dead - shuttered for the winter.
And then September is the cheapest time in Florida. A great bargain for hurricane enthusiasts.
Why drive all the way to Provincetown-Race Point Beach when the Cape Cod Seashore beaches are much more beautiful. Same with the Dennis, MA and Falmouth beaches.
Horseneck State Park in Westport is a long drive but one of the most beautiful beaches in the world.
Wingaersheek Beach in Gloucester is the best for kids. Slow tides in and out so can watch them play safely. Small pools let children see crabs, clams, snails and multi-colored worms. Further out, big waves when you get chest high. No riptide but a moderate current across so you can swim with or against the current for long swims.
Several weathered rocks that kids love to play on. A clean brackish river enters on the east end with a canal that opens its gates and drawbridge allows Atlantic Ocean fishing boats safe harbor or access to Ipswich Bay.
Caution: small parking lot so get there before 9:30 am.
Bonus: small parking lot means a lot of space to yourself and for long walks.
Keep off the fragile plants.
Gloucester is the place for lobster and clam chowder. Great restaurants and bars. Pratty’s on the fishing pier is the bar where ocean-going fishermen and women congregate. Fun place for pool and Red Sox games on the big screen and several TVs above the bar.
In May and June you might see the Bruins in the playoffs if they get their s**t together.