Agree about Gilmour the musician. Another anecdote - my mother-in-law got us tickets to a concert where the Florida Symphony Orchestra combined with a Pink Floyd tribute band to do an orchestral riff on Pink Floyd songs. What I found interesting was how much better the songs which were written by Gilmour translated to that format as opposed to the Waters tunes.
Plus, Roger Waters is an ass. :-)
Speaking of Gilmour.
This is one of the most criminally underrated Floyd songs.
Wots Uh The Deal? (Funny title, but I absolutely love this song)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k6JpS1XYGJQ
Glad to see he still plays it live in his concerts.