I was raised Baptist, however, as an adult have been Presbyterian and in a Bible church. In all of those churches we sang hymns written by the three mentioned.
Sorry, I misspelled Watts’ name. It should have been Isaac Watts not Wyatts.
My Grandfather was Presbyterian as well as a good majority of my family on my father’s side. How did I end up Catholic? My Grandmother was Catholic and back in the older days, I believe that that fathers would defer to the mothers religion for the kids. My Grandmother on my Mothers side was Baptist...now how did I end up Catholic??? Well for some reason my Grandmother allowed the kids to grow up Catholic as my Grandfather on my mother’s side was Catholic. It is quite a story but true. So we have both of your religions covered in my family.