Donofrio's response is not an "epic" "throwdown," and he does not convincingly respond to the coding error explanation. He merely states that the cases were correct in 2006/2007 (after they were updated with hyperlinks), and then were incorrect in 2008; from this, he concludes that they must have been intentionally altered. This is only a "throwdown" if one assumes that the hyperlink update in 2006/2007 was the
only update to Justia's databases; most sites as large as Justia, though, are almost constantly being updated/maintained, so the potential for a coding error after 2006/2007 is most certainly present. Donofrio simply ignores that.
Donofrio also ignores the point that others have made, that there were plenty of errors in other cases, having nothing to do with Minor and nothing to do with Presidential eligibility.
I find it odd that the error concerned that particular bunch of court cases. The GOP has historically not fought the dirty tricks of our enemies and we are all paying for that shortcoming. On the surface it would appear that our side simply cannot believe that our enemies are capable of the many machinations that they have used on their road to a global totalitarian state. That is a very serious error.