It’s not what I want to believe, it’s what SCOTUS has said. See Rogers v. Bellei.
Rogers v. Bellei doesn’t say what you think.
Again, I am puzzled as to why you wish to bring up Rogers v. Bellei. That cases establishes that a "born citizen" is not the same thing as a "natural born citizen." A more damaging blow to your argument I cannot fathom.
Also I am continuously puzzled by those who keep saying "let us see what SCOTUS said!" as opposed to "Let us read what the FOUNDERS said." The former argument implies that there are those of you who do not know what to think unless a third party tells you what your opinion should be.