[Seizethecarp]

“Maybe I’ve been missing something. Isn’t that a fact that Barry has admitted for many years? Has ANYONE claimed that Obama SR was a US citizen - ever?”

Until this past week there was never a plaintiff with standing and a trial on the merits with a path to SCOTUS and Barry has never allowed legal discovery of a physical certified BC, either long or short form, so this ruling is the first time that this potentially damaging “finding of fact” has been established in a case that can be appealed to SCOTUS.

Yes, Ankeny’s interpretaion of WKA that you prefer won the day with Malihi, but success of this interpretation of WKA is not certain to be affirmed ultimately by SCOTUS, IMO.

We shall see...

[Mr Rogers]

What makes you think this is on a path to the Supreme Court?

And why would anyone think something Obama has admitted his entire life needs a finding of the court to be considered?

How does this rejection - and for the record, I was hoping Obama would be removed from the ballot, which WOULD have set up a Supreme Court decision - help the birther case in any way?

[tired_old_conservative]

“Yes, Ankeny’s interpretaion of WKA that you prefer won the day with Malihi, but success of this interpretation of WKA is not certain to be affirmed ultimately by SCOTUS, IMO.”

It’s about as certain as anything human gets.