Replies

The law is what the law is. If you do not understand what the law is, then simply read the Ankeny v. Governor decision, the second part dealing with natural born citizenship.

Statute law cannot overturn the meaning of the Constitution, upon which all statute law rests. I've only recently begun seeing those whom we lovingly call 'after-birthers', refer to that case on FR.

I've been a part of the Birther conversations on Free Republic since Obama's run for office first sparked them. I have spent hundreds of hours following those conversations, and studying countless references elsewhere. I haven't read the case you refer to, but I must say that I'm surprised that few have mentioned it, until now.

Given that I haven't read up on that case, I won't argue the merits of it with you tonight. I will say, that in the last few days, I've seen some well-informed Freepers dismiss it, as regards this issue.

You're new here, so I don't know how much time you've spent immersed in this subject. What I can tell you, is that this subject has been discussed and debated here more than any single topic that I'm aware of. So much so, in fact, there's a section of Free Republic entirely devoted to it.

To come to the point, you're holding the minority view about the NBC clause, so you've got your work cut out for you. You've got a very long debate ahead.

There is NO debate. All you have to do is read the cases. Like the decision that just got handed down in Georgia. And Ankeny is real good. Why debate what the law is, when the judges are coming right out and telling you what the law is, and backing up their decision with quotes from the applicable cases??? That is like debating who won the Super Bowl football thingy. There's no debate. The New York football people won and already had a parade and everything. Same here. The courts are already ruling on this stuff so what is there to debate???

I am not new here. I was a Common Sense Suspicious Birther until April of this year, and even worked with another freeper to produce the youtube video, "Show Me The BirthFAX."

But I have NEVER bought into this two citizen parent lunacy. It is simply NOT the law. I have my own Think Tank, and since last summer, most of my Internet Articles are ones debunking the two citizen parent stuff. (Prior to that it was mostly about discussing Obama's refusal to cough up his long form.)

Here is a good article of mine to work you through your difficulties. This particular Internet Article really irritated Mario Apuzzo, Esq. Tee Hee! Tee Hee!:

A Place To Get The REALLY Right Answers About Natural Born Citizenship