Posted on 03/26/2012 5:24:06 PM PDT by WesternCulture
“the Finns were lucky they were fighting the Soviet conscription machine”
- Good point, it probably all comes down to plain luck.
I could easily consent to that description, provided we also could agree Finland were “lucky” having
- a potent western neighbor on their side supplying them with all of the first class goods needed to resist the invading forces of Stalin
- an insane leader of the enemy who decided to eliminate 75% of his officers before attacking Finland, a nation widely known for its ability of successfully participating in every kind of warfare as well as its fierce, bitter hatred of everything Russian
Russia ought to be awarded some kind of Nobel Prize for surviving the largest amount of incompetent leaders of all nations there has ever been.
I point out the fact that Finland was under Russian rule in the 1800s and there was not a peep. Finland was under Swedish rule before that and the Karelian Finns have been under Russian rule for centuries.
The Tsarist troops were better prepared for a Finnish war than the Soviet conscripts for the simple reason that the Soviet commandants, political commissars were not army men, did not plan their strategy beyond using men as cannon fodder and did not have a proper supply chain set up.
Russia deserves a Nobel Prize (though that is devalued ever since Obama won) yes, for having centuries of misery -- ever since the Mongol invasion
you mean Nazi Germany? Well, the Finns had no choice in that. It was a choice between the lesser of two evils. -- they could not rely on neutral, small Sweden to defend it.
The Swedes had been comprehensively defeated by the Russians in the Finnish war of 1808.
the Swedish leader Cronstedt retreated and the Russians took over most of Finland with no resistance.
By the Treaty of Fredrikshamn, this was finalized and Finland became part of the Tsardom
Sweden was ill-prepared to fight in WWII --> it had hardly a handful of Stridsvagn tanks, about 15-20 in 1937.
During the winter war, 8000 Swedes fought on the side of the Finns (after all they had ruled the finns for 600 years)
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.