Atlantic Editor Wonders If Morsi Wants to Be Dictator or Abe Lincoln

NewsBusters ^ | November 25, 2012 | P.J. Gladnick

[Sherman Logan]

I have no clue what you mean by that post. Try to be a little more coherent and I’ll be glad to reply.

Look, nobody is claiming that the Union was based on initial full implementation of the ideal that “all men are created equal.” Obviously not. However, that ideal was always there, however imperfectly addressed.

Until the CSA explicitly pronounced that the Founders were wrong in their claim that “all men are created equal,” that the new CSA was founded on the cornerstone truth that some men aren’t equal, they are by nature slaves to the master race.

[GeronL]

If I remember correctly the House passed a Constitutional amendment to ban any constitutional amendments to ban slavery, the Senate also passed it 2 days later and President Buchanan signed it the same day.

Lincoln was sworn in a day later. He apparently did not campaign against the Constitutional amendment.

Only 3 states ratified it, though. So nothing ever came of it, even though it was a huge deal to those in Congress in those few days.

[Tublecane]

I was thinking if the amendment, yes, and had the South capitulated and returned to the union Lincoln could have backed up the carrot by pushing for the requisite states to ratify.

I was also thinking of the Fugitive Slave Act, which Lincoln repeatedly vowed to enforce and repeal of which he fought against.

[Tublecane]

I was thinking of the amendment, yes, and had the South capitulated and returned to the union Lincoln could have backed up the carrot by pushing for the requisite states to ratify.

I was also thinking of the Fugitive Slave Act, which Lincoln repeatedly vowed to enforce and repeal of which he fought against.

[GeronL]

I think he said he wouldn’t fight that amendment, but he didn’t have to apparently.

[Sherman Logan]

You may have fallen for Lincoln’s pet trick of pretending the Republic originated not with ratification of the Constitution, but rather in the foggy realm of the mystical cords of memory represented by the Declaration.

How very tricky of Lincoln!

Nobody else has ever thought this, which is why our national holiday is celebrated in June not July.