[Seizethecarp]

“So are you believing that NBC has debunked Zullo’s claims?”

I am taking a forensic approach here neither “believing” nor advocating NBC’s claims as true but rather trying to accurately state NBC’s claims and letting others with expertise assess those claims.

NBC claims to have replicated every pdf anomaly with the exception of the “halos” and has put up a pdf file to prove it. He has also posted his extensive record of trial and error in getting to the equipment and workflow that he claims results in the replicated pdf. If his claims are false, then it is up to debunkers to attack his pdf, IMO.

Zullo has always said that he would withdraw his claim that the WH pdf “never existed as a paper document” if someone could show a “one-touch” replication. NBC claims to have shown a three step replication which meets Zullo’s essential challenge, if true, IMO.

As to the curvature issue, that would have existed on the hard copy LFBC that NBC claims was fed into the Xerox so the curvature is not an artifact of compression.

[GregNH]

I have not been following this Xerox thread with much interest. But it appears to me that 1) The only Xerox created PDF was a tax return. I would be surprised if Zippos tax return was done and processed in the WH, but I will let that go.

2) NBC has not shown any evidence that the WH LFBC was scanned with a Xerox.

[Cold Case Posse Supporter]

What if NBC is programming his computer to make you think he is replicating every PDF anomaly? Ever consider that?

[GeorgeWashingtonsGhost]

And what caused halos? I know what caused the halo around all bitmap characters and lines in his bc. It occurred when someone took the black areas of text and lines which were originally on a white background then ‘selected/wanded’ them (’tolerance’ set to high %)in Photoshop or Illustrator (’contiguous’ OFF) and dragged them onto the ‘green security paper graphic’ layer.. In doing so, the white areas surrounding all text and lines carried over onto the green security paper graphic layer. I am convinced this is how the halos occurred, and have replicated this myself. No doubts about it, whatsoever. Whoever did this didn’t know that halos can be avoided by simply dragging the layer and changing layer opacity so white disappears which tells me the graphics person wasn’t a top tier graphics person. Probably Alex Okrent who died of a sudden heart attack (same as Breitbart) at the age of 29.