Right but what I am talking about here is the CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT of the State legislature to choose the electors if there was a VIOLATION of state election law.
If the state’s highest court ruled the practice legal than it was legal. SCOTUS’ responsibility is whether the action conflicts with the Constitution or federal law. It took no stance on that so the voting practices are in line with Pa state law since Pa Aupreme Court ruled they are. State legislature is by law omitted from the electoral process unless fuether evidence can change the Couet’s mind.