Without Rose, the Hall is just a list of players. Google Hall of famers and murder. Ty Cobb beat a bum to death just for asking for money.
Whoa Hoss! That's blashemy! Ruth, Hornsby, Cy Young, Hammering Hank Aaron, Ty Cobb, Willie Mays, Mickey Mantle, Lou Gehrig et al just a list of names without Rose?
I think not. Seriously.
I don't care who Cobb beat to death on the street he was the greatest hitter that ever lived and he didn't bet on baseball and get caught. Rose was a silly jackass that couldn't pick the flesh and mud out of Ty Cobb's spikes.