does anyone else here hate Katherine? I think she is very over-rated and that she deserved to be in the bottom two. She also is not nearly as good as she should be with a vocal coach for a mom. When Elliott was named to be in the bottom two she only was excited for her-self and did not look sad for elliott at all. Elliott on the other hand is always so considerate of the other contestants when they are named the bottom singer. He turned to Paris immediately and seemed so genuinely sorry. I think Elliott is probably the most selfless American Idol ever. What a great guy and an awesome singer! He sounded awesome tonight when he sang Broadway. Half way into it he got so confidant and was like 10 times better than he did last night. Without his nerves he would be a no question shoe in for the top two. Katherine on the other hand always seems really fake and tonight AI was pimping her hard core. I hated how she tried to pull the pickler "i was really bad on that song" sympathy vote. Based on the behind the scene videos and her body language it does not seem like the contestants are very close with her. She's always standing kind of far away from the other idols. I just hope she goes home next week. Elliott does not deserve to go home before her!!!!
I feel like elliott has a much bigger fan base too.... it seems weird that she has been in the top group two weeks in a row when dial idol showed elliott higher both times. i know its wrong a lot but... does anyone think AI put her in the top group even though she had lower votes? Nigel has openly gushed over kat and doesn’t seem to be much of an elliott or taylor fan... just seems a littttle weird
I don't hate her, but she's never been one of my favorites. She's got a good voice, but doesn't show much personality.
I like her but now that Kellie and Paris are gone people need someone else to hate.
I was impressed by that. He seems to be the most improved singer during the show IMHO.
I think Katherine is just awful. I never could understand why she hasn't been booted off. I did hear the stories about how her father and friends have been loading the votes. Maybe so. Who else could vote for her?
Katharine was raised to be a pampered princess. It is very evident. Probably has never had a real hardship in her life. When one does come her way, she won't know how to cope, because mom and dad have done it for her. I feel sorry for her in a way.
Did they say Katharine was in the top two? She could have been in the middle.
Only all of the women who are jealous that she's talented and a bombshell. ;)