Skip to comments.Sam Raimi Will Direct The Hobbit?
Posted on 01/28/2007 4:33:14 PM PST by maquiladora
There has been speculation about this since last November but according to a major newspaper, Sam "Spider-Man" Raimi is considering directing The Hobbit.
LA Times has the following:
In a move that would have ramifications for several major multi-nationals, and millions of fans, "Spider-Man" maestro Sam Raimi has been telling associates, as well as his corporate masters at Sony, that he is thinking of directing "The Hobbit," the prequel to J.R.R. Tolkien's masterwork, "The Lord of the Rings." At least two top-level insiders who declined to be named -- have heard the words out of the director's mouth.
A year ago, such a swap of franchises would have been unthinkable, given that Peter Jackson co-wrote and directed the Oscar-winning "Rings" trilogy, but that was before the slugfest erupted between the once-rotund director and New Line honcho Bob Shaye.
Jackson is suing the studio over money he says is owed to him from the the "Rings" films, which grossed more than $3 billion at the box office and another $1 billion on DVD. In the last few weeks, Shaye has declared Jackson persona-non-grata at New Line, stating publicly that, "He will never make any movie with New Line Cinema again while I'm still working at the company."
According to a New Line source, the studio isn't just contemplating one "Hobbit" movie, but two. The prequel tells the story of hobbit Bilbo Baggins and how he first discovers the magical but sinister ring, the very object that drives the action in "Lord of the Rings."
Still, while Raimi might be an irresistable replacement for Jackson, his ascension to the directing chair is far from a sure thing. New Line says it doesn't have a deal with the director, and Raimi hasn't met with Shaye or production president Toby Emmerich. More potentially problematic is the fact that MGM owns the distribution rights to the film. An MGM spokeman insists that MGM remains firmly in the Jackson camp: "We support Peter Jackson, and when the dust settles, we believe he is the one who will be making this movie."
A call to Raimi's office was directed to his agent, Richard Lovett, at CAA. The agency did not comment.
For Sony, losing Raimi who gave "Spider-Man" its distinctive visual theatrics would be a blow. Studio chief Amy Pascal has said she wants to make six installments of the "Spider-Man" tale. Just this week, the studio announced it was rehiring David Koepp, who wrote the first film, to write "Spider-Man 4."
Ring ping :o)
I'm with them...
Hobbit Hole Troop support blog.
Anyone wishing to be added to or removed from the Ring-Ping list, please don't hesitate to let me know.
Rats. I was hoping for the Farrellys. Woody Harrelson as Frodo "Munson" Baggins would be cool.
If New Line has any sense, they'll dump Shaye and bring back PJ.
There's an idea :~)
Fine, then get rid of Shaye. It's Peter or nothing.
I think that's a major sentiment. I don't think they'd be wise to completely disregard the loyalties of the fans.
Yah! I was watching Disc Five (Appendixes) of the LOTR movies this afternoon. Peter Jackson, or don't do it. Without him, the movies wouldn't have been possible.
Ordesky said that New Line has a limited time option on the film rights they have obtained from Saul Zaentz (this has never been conveyed to us before), and because we won't discuss making the movies until the lawsuit is resolved, the studio is going to have to hire another director.
Haven't found anything definitive on the issue yet. The idea broached of a Hobbit AND another "prequel" sends shivers through the spine of this LOTR purist. I remember Ralph Bakshi...
Yeah as far as I'm aware, the rights go back to Saul Zaentz at the end of this year unless it's in production.
I'd say if wasn't for Tolkien, the movies wouldn't have been possible. It doesn't matter to me who directs, as long as he/she respects the original material.
My thought as well. All of it would be impossible, it's too disjointed, but perhaps the story of Beren and Luthien and the fight against Morgoth? Or perhaps Isildur's story from the Second Age? You could probably get a movie out of either but there isn't a great deal of material for a screenplay.
1) The Hobbit - an adaptation of the book as we know it
2) LOTR prequel - a film documenting the events between The Hobbit and the start of Fellowship
Ah, thank you. Most interesting. Those events are a bit sketchy but I suppose they'd include the White Council's attack on Dol Guldur and Sauron's flight to Mordor. Perhaps the seduction and fall of Saruman. Maybe the re-awakening of the Nazgul. Beyond that I'm going on memory and it's coming up a little dry...
LOTRs were just the last books in a long line of Tolkien mythology. The wrap ups to the middle age.
The "prequell" books are quite awesome, try the simarillion, and the akallabeth.
As far a PJ, he rewrote too much for my taste. Half of the last book gone pffft like it never happened.
The real reason Jackson had such great success with the trillogy was he had awesome material to begin with. Look at King Kong, 2hrs of Jack Black in 20s NYC, when all anyone wanted to see was the monkey.
Rami rocks!!!! Very innovative camera angles, and infusion of comedy.
I can't imagine anyone other than Peter Jackson directing the Hobbbit.
While I had a few exceptions to his treatment of LOTR, overall his adaption was pretty darn good.
Nobody else could have pulled it off.
Right, The Hobbit is NOT a prequel to LotR. It's a stand on it's own book, it just happened to have happened before the time of LotR.
How many billions did Shaye make for New Line?
All Shaye has to do is keep his mouth shut, and spend his cut of the money PJ will make for him. Being a liberal, he can't even recognize his own best interests.
I can't see how that could be done in less than....say....twelve parts or so.
Perhaps Raimi could do an indie "Evil Dead" version of "The Hobbit"? As long as Bruce Campbell is in it...
I notice that there are a lot of scenes in "Army of Darkness" that reappear in Jackson's LOTR.
I heard rumors about that! One said that Ashton Kutcher was being considered for Ash. Blecch!!
Not being an LOTR fan, I didn't see that pic. But I did enjoy "Army of Darkness"!
Shaye better not be so smug. Has ANY movie franchise made the kind of money for New Line that the LOTR series has made? I thought I'd read that New Line's option on "The Hobbit" runs out this year, anyway. If that happens, New Line won't have any say about it anymore, anyway.
My take as well.
I love the work of both Jackson and Raimi. I can see a situation where Jackson is the producer and Raimi directs, though. But I bet part of any deal is that Shaye says bye bye. A Hollywood executive should never get into a pissing match with a director who has made billions of dollars with their films (even if their next movie "only" made half a billion dollars). No matter the outcome, in the long run the director almost always wins and the executive almost always gets a golden parachute, but lots fewer party invitations.
Harry Knowles (the lefty film geek operator of the great movie geek site Aint It Cool News) is friends with both of the directors. Let's let him work out the deal.
The one problem I'd have with Raimi is I can't think of a character in The Hobbit for Bruce Campbell to play! No problem with casting his brother Ted Raimi. He's used to performing in "sword operas." I just hope he doesn't bring to much of Joxer to any role.
And Zaentz will have every reason to sue to regain the rights if New Line plays any games whatever about "in production".
I think Bruce would make a GREAT Gollum!
Yeah, "Army of Darkness" is one of my favorites.
OK, so now we'll have the Hobbit shot in "shaky-cam," with Bruce Campbell playing the Dwarves. All of them. ;)
If there was any justice those rights would go to John Fogerty, but that's another story...
"Good...bad...I'm the hobbit with The Ring."
A hobbit with a boomstick... I like it!
All right you primitive screwheads, listen up. See this? This is my BOOMSTICK! It's a 12-gauge double-barralled Remington. S-Mart's top of the line. You can find this in the sporting goods department. That's right. This sweet baby was made in Grand Rapids, Michigan. It retails for about $109.95. It's got a walnut stock, cobalt blue steel, and a hair trigger. That's right! Shop smart. Shop S-Mart.
What role will Bruce Campbell get?
So the most likely senario will be...production rights go back to Tolkien Enterprises at the end of the year and then MGM & Tolkien Enterprises try making The Hobbit with Jackson with no New Line involvement whatsoever.
IMO Peter Jackson would not do a good job with The Hobbit. It is a children's story.
OMG....ASH RULES !
Whoops, how'd that happen? It's been remedied. :)
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.