[Netizen]

It could be that, but generally if a performer has an original and/or flexible style, it's there no matter what song they sing. With Michael Johns, no matter what song he chooses, his performance style is always within a narrow -- or maybe the better word would be flat band. It's hard to find the words to explain what I mean. He just has no dimension to his performances. I think it has more to do with a flat emotionless quality than anything else.

What I was thinking is that they might be choosing songs they like and their likes might lean to a particular preference, which might not always be the best choice. Kind of like the gals that all want to sing Whitney, even though they can't, but that doesn't stop them from trying! lol

I think I know what you mean about Johns' sound. Going back to Paula seeing them sing in colors. He would be monochromatic.

[Wolfstar]

I think I know what you mean about Johns' sound. Going back to Paula seeing them sing in colors. He would be monochromatic.

Yep. That's as good a way as any to put it. You're also right that many of the contestants choose songs that don't really suit their styles.