Well...that is why it is called freedom of choice and we all have different opinions. My opinion is you are crazy and wouldn't know good TV if it fell off the shelf and hit you in the head.
This is a great show. You want to see bad acting? Watch Star Trek TOS. Its still a great show...but some of the acting is horrible (especially by Shatner). Babylon 5...another popular show...one I can't watch because of the acting. BSG has great acting.
I would have to say Andromeda tops them all... To me Babylon 5 tops them all. To each his or her own..