Posted on 08/23/2011 5:05:54 PM PDT by nickcarraway
Santa Clara native was apparently prone to sleeping on guard duty; fellow Marines took to disciplining him.
U.S. Marine Corps Lance Corporal Harry Lew took his own life in his foxhole in Afghanistan after he was kicked and punched by fellow Marines, military officials tell NBC Bay Area news.
An investigation into the 21-year-old's April death says Lew "leaned over his M249 squad automatic weapon as it pointed to the sky, placed the muzzle in his mouth and pulled the trigger."
Lew wrote on his arm: "may hate me now, but in the long run this was the right choice I'm sorry my mom deserves the truth."
The suicide came moments after fellow Marines attacked Lew for repeatedly falling asleep on guard duty. An investigation shows Lew, from Santa Clara, was caught asleep at least four separate times in areas where "enemy attack was considered imminent." Military records show Lew, who was on his first tour in Afghanistan, was first counseled then disciplined by a sergeant for sleeping while on post.
At some point, Lew was forced to walk his rounds while carrying a single sandbag, symbolic of the weight of his responsibility to his fellow marines.
On April 3, Lew could not be raised by radio while standing post. A check of his foxhole found him asleep once again.
The unnamed sergeant then announced over the radio that "peers should correct peers," according to military documents. That led to what appears to be a sad series of events.
Fellow lance corporals [whose names have been redacted in the report] ordered Lew to dig a new foxhole as a punishment, then informed Lew he could go to sleep once the task was finished. Those corporals, however, did not inform the sergeant they had given Lew permission to sleep.
At 1:00 a.m., that sergeant, whose name has also been redacted from the report, "angrily confronted [Lew] about why he had again fallen asleep." Other Marines then demanded Lew to perform various physical tasks as punishment and would "stomp down" on Lew's back and legs if he failed to do an exercise properly.
"Towards the end of the physical training", the report says a "sandbag broke open at which point lance corporal [redacted] picked it up and poured the contents on Lew's chest and face as he lay with his back to the ground."
Convinced Lew was responding to his punishment with sarcasm and disrespect, fellow lance corporals then "kicked dirt on Lew, kicked him in the back of the helmet, punched him in the back of his helmet with a force that cut [his attacker's] knuckle."
At some point, a fellow Marine stepped in to stop the attack, saying he didn't "want it on his conscience if Lew killed himself" -- which is exactly what Lew did.
A sergeant is blamed in the report for giving responsibility for Lew's discipline to fellow marines.
"Further, he failed to intervene while those peers undertook inappropriate corrective actions." That sergeant faces court martial when the unit returns from Afghanistan, as does an unnamed lance corporal.
The military says unequivocally that Lew took his own life, though it the report does indicated more than one round was shot from Lew's SAW.
"This command mourns the death of Lance Corporal Lew" reads the final report. "His family and friends have my deepest sympathies" says his commanding officer.
Lew is a 2008 graduate of Santa Clara High School and was assigned to the 2nd battalion, 3rd marine regiment, 3rd Marine division.
His obituary in the San Francisco Chronicle says Lew wrote "Brand new Marine, feels good" on his Myspace page shortly after he joined the military.
When I first arrived in South Korea there had been an incident where a South Korean fell asleep on guard duty in the ammo dump.
His Lt didn’t even wake him up, just put a bullet in his head.
Basic and AIT pretty much discover folks with a sleep problem. Ordinarily they aren't subjected to this sort of treatment ~ they are simply given a discharge.
The military has no reason to keep folks around who have some reason why they can't do the job or who have physical abnormalities like Peronie's Disease that could very well mislead field medics regarding an injured soldier's condition.
When the military discover someone with Borderline Personality Disorder they release him or her from the service. It's useless to punish them, or hope to correct them.
Guard duty is exceptionally difficult for some individuals ~ for others it's just a waking trance away from another day of good times eh.
War is hell. He let is fellow Marines down. I would have not been very happen with him either...
This was NCO business. If the NCO recommended an Article 15 to his PL or CO and they declined to pursue it for an invalid reason, then that would be abdication of responsibility. As it stands, it was POS kid who couldn't do what he was supposed to do.
thats my thought
And what ever happened to giving the guy a live grenade to hold?
1. If the USMC is like the Army, then that won't happen.
2. We don't really know what happened anyway.
Falling asleep on guard duty used to carry a severe penalty with it (it starts with an “e” and ends with an “n”) - and for very good reason.
Don't be silly. This guy is at a particular position and he's on alert and other folks are wandering about checking on him and others ~ so it's not like a whole platoon, or company, or battalion, or brigade, or division, or Army GROUP is at risk if he nods off.
It's mostly his butt that's at risk, and his buddy's butt too.
The potential for damage is limited through application of normal doctrines.
What I don't understand in this one is that someone thought using the techniques one might use to break a slave would improve self-discipline. Today it's recognized this sort of thing induces some pretty serious depression. I really doubt the guys doing this were taught in the military how this can be done.
Sad story no matter how you cut. But a sadder one would be “Platoon surprised by attack, ten dead.”
Hasn’t “Sleeping on Guard Duty” historically been a Capital offense?
The privileges of nobles are very circumscribed these days.
Just profound sadness here from the father of a Marine LC - soon getting promoted.
I hear you, dad.
“So, you’re in a combat situation and everybody but you is allowed to sleep ~ NOT!”
Not while he’s on post. This isn’t the post office. People die when people fall asleep on guard duty.
“Don’t be silly.”
Just shut up mail man, you know nothing of having your life depend on those around you. He risked lives because he was too lazy to stay awake. Its sad that he killed himself but to minimize it is ignorant.
Anyone should know the discipline required to serve. If he couldn't handle it there are ways out. He was the one that chose to kill himself. No one else.
That would be too stupid to be believed in any modern military unit.
Sleep apnea will certainly make it tougher to stay awake, but from experience these guys are often exhausted and it’s tough to keep alert in these circumstances, hence the widespread use of chew, cigs, coffee, etc. Black coffee always worked for me.
Sleep apnea will certainly make it tougher to stay awake, but from experience these guys are often exhausted and it’s tough to keep alert in these circumstances, hence the widespread use of chew, cigs, coffee, etc. Black coffee always worked for me.
I am sorry if my comments sound brutal, but falling asleep on guard duty in a combat zone is unforgivable. Others lives depend on your watchfulness. Falling asleep on guard duty is breaking faith with your fellow marines/soldiers/sailors/airmen. He deserved some very severe punishment. It didn't, however, have to be physical. Nevertheless, I understand his follow marines' rage.
It happened four freaking times??!! Why wasn't he removed and given judicial punishment and sent to work as a cook after the second offense? If he had a sleep disorder, why was he given combat duty at all? How do even get through basic training without learning how to stay awake? He really was endangering his fellow marines. Sorry if that sounds brutal, but the marines are in life and death situations over there every day and night, and you HAVE GOT to pull your weight.
No expert here, but where was the discipline. Discipline would not permit this in an orderly unit. Either the sleeping or the reaction to it.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.