[Torahman]

So, basically, American Indians are Jews? Come on already! Does anyone really believe this? You mean to tell me that the Jews...Sold Manhattan...to the Dutch for 24 dollars worth of beads and trinkets?!! Heh Heh! Right...Good one!

[meatloaf]

They didn’t own it.

[Verginius Rufus]

Does anyone really believe this?

I assume Mormons do. I don't.

But to say there is DNA evidence disproving it requires assuming that modern-day Jews are descended from the ancient Israelites (that's a very reasonable belief based on what we know of Jewish history, and I think the DNA studies so far support it, but it's not like 2 + 2 = 4). If any American Indians have Jewish ancestry, it's from Jews who came to the New World after 1492.

[reaganaut]

Mormons believe it. Of course they also believe that the Garden of Eden was in Missiouri (I’m not kidding).

I am reaganaut, and I am an ex-Mormon.

[Elsie]

So, basically, American Indians are Jews? Come on already! Does anyone really believe this?

It sure LOOKS that way!!