Free Republic
Browse · Search
General/Chat
Topics · Post Article

To: ken5050; Little Ray; null and void; Sherman Logan
The article exaggerates. Firstly, the Sepoy Rebellion was mainly in the Gangetic plain and in contrast the Tamils, Sikhs and Nepalis supported the British against the Moguls

Secondly, the "give the best shot" indicates a pre-determined plan. There wasn't

Thirdly the Kanpur (or Cawnpore) massacre is as Sherman points out, chaotic and hardly planned

As Sherman points out correctly Horrible atrocities were indeed committed by both sides, though the number of Indians murdered by the Brits is probably a large multiple (20x, 50x, 100x, who knows?) of the Brits murdered by Indians. This is largely because there just weren't that many Brits in India at the time, while there were lots and lots of Indians available for slaughter.

The point is that while these atrocities happened, the true nature of events bears little semblance to this definition of a "Perfect Day."

Sherman, I would also state that the ignorance of the article's author is because many people think of India as one country while it isn't -- the people of Punjab and of Madras as different nations, different races and their languages are as similar as Italian and Japanese

The "Indian Mutiny" was really just the "Gangetic north Indian mutiny" and even then it was mainly brought on by the erstwhile rulers trying to get back their power to collect more money

The common people saw the British as just another tax collector, no better, no worse

And for Tamils, Sikhs etc., the British were better than the Moslem rulers or the Marathas (to some extent)

34 posted on 06/30/2013 11:27:43 PM PDT by Cronos (Latin presbuteros>Late Latin presbyter->Old English pruos->Middle Engl prest->priest)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 3 | View Replies ]


To: Cronos; ken5050; Little Ray; Sherman Logan
You are making the HUGE assumption that the muzzies learned nothing from the Sepoy rebellion, that next time such a slaughter won't be deliberate, planned, co-ordinated and universal.

That's why I cited Huế, In that case it was deliberate, planed, and co-ordinated The result? Everyone with a history of cooperating with the Americans and every member of the government and every member of their families were murdered in a single night.

The Sepoy revolt isn't a piece of malicious software that can only be robotically followed to inevitable failure, it, like all other military actions, is a learning experience.

The kid fell off the bicycle in 1857, I think he can give riding it a very good go today.

38 posted on 07/01/2013 7:09:43 AM PDT by null and void (Republicans create the tools of oppression, and the democrats gleefully use them!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 34 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
General/Chat
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson