I quite agree. That’s why nobody is claiming a naturalized citizen is eligible to be elected president.
The argument is between those who consider all citizens at birth to be NBC, and those who consider NBC a special subset of citizens at birth.
I’m in the first camp. YMMV
If it is just a matter of what one or more persons ‘consider’ this or that I don’t see how there is or can be any established legal/Constitutional standing. That is why I go back to the explicit different requirements as designated in the Constitution for POTUSA and Congresspersons.