Elway said Tebow was the type of guy he would like to see his daughter marry, just didn't see Tebow as a long term solution to the Bronco QB problem. That problem was nicely put to rest with Payton Manning's arrival in Denver.
As far as Elway's treatment of players you are not likely to find many in the NFL who would agree that he treats his players poorly. There's a very strong possibility John Elway will be this seasons recipient of the NFL executive of the year award. To go next to his first round selection to the NFL Hall of Fame award in his trophy case.
Honestly there are no easy answers.
Had Peyton stayed with the Colts, could he have brought it home? Maybe. Andrew Luck is pretty good.
Could Tim bring it home? Maybe. He's pretty young.
With hundreds of million dollars riding on your decision, I truly don't know the answer.
Tebow "may" be a great QB, but benching him makes NO kind of sense.
Use him, or trade him.
Sanchez REALLY sucks, and I'm not a NYJ fan.