Oh, man, you’re making my mouth water! We used to go to the WindMill in Ocean Grove (or was it Belmar?) when we visited my relatives in Neptune City!
It was Belmar, right where Rt 35 diverges from Rt 71. Right on the corner. I used to live 2 miles south of there in Spring Lake Heights.
I have frequent client calls in Bricktown, right across from their location there. The store is closed for renovations. I'm pissed.