Skip to comments.Is it common to have to provide my SS# for claim? (Vanity)
Posted on 09/09/2013 9:29:12 AM PDT by Java4Jay
My daughter just called and said her dentist needs my SS# to file a claim. She is 25 and covered under my policy. This seemed very odd so I came to FR for answers.Feedback welcome, thanks.
Maybe under upcoming ObaMugabeCare?
That was my exact thought also
Could insurance coverage now be taxable? Everyone said dental wouldn’t be affected under obamacare. Could this be another instance of “we had to pass it to see what was in it”?
It depends how your third party administrator uniquely identifies your family. Some still use the Employee SSN, many have switched to other identifiers. Check the card, it’s always on there.
Legally you can only be required to provide your SSN for SS and income tax purposes. But even the government ignores this.
Is this a surprise when the IRS is in charge of healthcare!
I’ve carried the same Blue Cross plan for many years and this is the first time I recall this ever happening.
The claim is for a normal cleaning which is covered biannually.
They’re asking for the SSN in case they need to send a bill to collections. They probably also asked for an employer and other information that will help them collect a debt.
I always put 123-45-6789.
There must be a claim form....probably even on line...see what it says.
I think it this is needed for “proof for services” or some such thing. It’s to prevent other people for stealing your health insurance coverage.
Also, not unusual if there is another person in the area with the same name as you to have to provide SS# and Birth date.
I know my Medicare No. is my SS#.
You insurance policy uses SS# as IDs, since it’s your policy they need your number.
It is not uncommon.
Just tell her to give them a bogus number.
Same thing I do when a dept store wants my address and phone number. I don’t argue, I just make something up.
only give them your last four digits. that should be enough.
You are correct, her registration form ask who is responsible for your account charges? I’m NOT responsible, its between my daughter, doctor and insurance company.
Demand theirs be sent home on all documents that ask for mine or my child's. As is good for me, is good for thee.
I have bcbs too and had the same issue with a biology practice. No they do not need a ss# to file a claim.
Ask the person asking you for their SS number first.
The filling out of any medical form, is akin to filling out an IRS form.
Anything that the IRS might ask you, ObamaCare may ask you.
You may be charged with a crime defined in federal statutes or by some federal agency's bureaucrats (whether or not defined in their regulations), for not answering ObamaCare questions and filling out forms truthfully.
"Truth" is effectively defined as what they, the IRS/ObamaCare have on file about you, which is now so much more, "thanks" to the Internet *and your habits online in addition to records of all your transaction activities.*
To wit: your dentist, your doctor, your care giver (who is an employee of a care giving organization) ... are all tantamount to being almost-IRS-agents.
The paperwork problem for you, is so enormous, that you may be directed to an ObamaCare "navigator," who is a government agent.
There is a lot of angst about the government's hiring of people to be "navigator" job applicants - re the government's claim that it does not have the time for background checks of "navigator" job applicants in addition to other issues.
Good luck with that, getting a decent government agent ... and being able to keep that person as your agent?
My guess is, that the Congress - lawyers - know that the bureaucracy of ObamaCare, will be ObamaCare's own un-doing; that ObamaCare will fail by its own weight, helped by THE GENERAL UN-HAPPINESS of the public.
My guess continues ... that the Congress will *then* have the will to end ObamaCare, which lack of fortitude *now* inhabits their guts.
Agreed, no matter how much they insist, BCBS can pay the claim just fine. I write “prefer not to give”
In NC anyway, its against state law to require it tho they can ask all they want.
I already have coverage, Obama said I could keep it
As a manager of a dental office, I can state that many dental benefit policies want to require that primary policy SSN# be provided when the dependent to assure coverage is appropriate. This prevents identity theft coverage. I.e., benefits being provided to a dependent who is not a dependent of the primary insured. The benefit provider is SUPPOSED to have generated a new, non-SSN number for this purpose as SSNs are not supposed to be used for ID purposes but many have not done it.
Also, the dentist may be requiring the parent’s SSN (not really allowed) so he may more easily collect a non-paid bill, assuming the parent might be a “responsible party,” which Obama has thrown into a legal limbo with his requirement for policies to cover legal adults until age twenty-six, an absurdity, and using the insurance company as an excuse to get it. You do have the legal right to refuse to provide the SSN for any purpose except a government one.
The dentist does not have to be paid directly by the benefit provider. Your daughter can pay the bill, and you can submit it for reimbursement.
I believe the House nullified the SSN protections a few years ago. Medical offices require them so they can turn you over to collections if you fail to pay up...
UPDATE: Dentist tried to submit claim electronically but it won’t let them without my numbers. Daughter has seen this dentist before with no issues.
My daughter is not my dependent, she is 25.
Unless you have another identification # on your dental policy, yes, he needs it.........
Daughter has her own card with her name and policy numbers on it
Seems like where this is going is the IRS will tax me for services rendered
Then I can't see any reason for the dentist to require YOUR SS#.........I'd personally talk to him about it.
there is no reason to give a ss#.
IOW just say no.
Normally required and legal are 2 different things.
Right on my SS card it states for SS benefits only and not to be used for ID.
By the way dental patients, check your bills carefully. In less that a year I have caught 4 different dentists/billing services charging more than the agreed upon payment for various carriers.
So far I have receive $277 back from one dental scam artist and I have another $250 in the works with the remaining 2 still under investigation.
Here is the scam. The dentist agrees CONTRACTUALLY with your Ins carrier to accept let say $1200 for a procedure.
The dentist will bill the carrier for $1450 (or more) and of course the Ins company will only pay $1200 and they will try to bill you for the rest. If the dentist agreed to accept the Ins. company’s payment as payment in full (that is my Ins. company agreement) then you should owe nothing.
WATCH your bills and I can only assume doctors will do the same.
One dentist tried to say the $207 was a lab charge which never showed up on the bill but that amount was exactly the difference between their original billing and what the Ins company paid. I expect that check in a week.
I just went through this with my doctor’s office. They never asked for it before and all of a sudden they “had to have it”. I did some research on the SS website. No, you do not have to give this number out. Unless you are under a government plan, like Medicare or Medicaid.
I also called my insurance company and they told me that they do NOT need my SS# to pay a claim. I am identified by another number, which is on my insurance card and not my SS#.
So I just politely said no and had no problems.
They would LIKE to have it for bill paying reasons. It makes it easier to find you if you don’t pay your bill. However just because some people are deadbeats is no reason for you to have to expose yourself to fraud. There are a couple of studies out there if you do the research that say a great portion of ID theft is from medical and dental offices.
The law does not require you to provide this to them but they hope that most people will just fill it in.
They could decide that they do not want to provide service to your daughter. Then you can either offer to pay cash or go to another dentist.
“There are a couple of studies out there if you do the research that say a great portion of ID theft is from medical and dental offices.”
I am unaware of these studies . Can you give me a URL? Thanks!
Others have suggested false numbers.
Or you can simply refuse and tell them why.
IOW just say no.
Thanks for clarifying that, I'm sure lots of folks would have been confused by my statement............
Here are some to get your started. Clark Howard did a segment on the topic and the worst places to give out your SS#. Medical offices were on the list.
This article will lead you to some information on government statistics and private research into the crime.
You can find more using a search engine. The law that I mentioned that exempts doctors, clinics, dentists is called the Red Flag Law or Red Flag Rule. The law does not consider these entities a “business”.
I did all of this research a couple of months ago and went armed with printouts to the doctor’s office and never had to use them. It was suggested that instead of dealing with the receptionist you ask to speak with the office manager or the physician themselves. Ask them why they want the information and what they intend to do with it and how they plan to protect your information.
I was told a number of bogus reasons by the receptionist. One told me she couldn’t enter an appointment without my SS# yet I made an appt. two weeks before that. I asked her what changed and she said they had a new computer system. The same one they had when I made my last appt. Then I was told by another receptionist that the insurance company needed the number to pay my claim. I called the insurance company and they said they did not. They already have my SS#. and do not print it on the card to protect clients from ID theft.
Soooo... The next story I was told is that because the injury I had was the result of a home accident they had to have it to fill in the form on the computer.
I just said “No” and suddenly they were able to leave that line blank.
A couple of weeks after I went to a place that does discount MRI’s and noticed that the form had a line for my SS# right at the top. I left it blank. No problem.
I know that, and YOU know that, but OBAMA, doesn't seem to know that!
Hmmmm... strange. I suspect that dentist wants it for his own purposes or the software is antique.
I am too... HIIPA laws are very explicit about patient privacy and are even more onerous than other places where data may be stolen. I think someone is making things up. I know that my clients' offices and my office are VERY careful of such data.
Please note that Medical Identity theft is really not that common. . . the 2009 cited 250,000 cases out of over 250,000,000 insured in this country. But the individual crooks really DON’T GET THE stolen IDs from medical offices... they mostly get them from the same common sources that regular ID thefts come from! They get individual Medical ID cards come from stolen wallets, stolen IDs, and Spoofing IDs from people. They do not go into medical offices to steal IDs.
One of the primary ways wholesale Medical Insurance records have been stolen in the past was the theft of Insurance Company laptop computers that were not encrypted. There were several stolen in the past that had Patient names, SSNs, and Subscriber IDs on them, along with employer data and addresses.... thousands. Insurance company employees have left them in cabs, on subways, or had them snatched from their shoulders in their carrying cases. The company servers have been hacked... that is how ID data is stolen and then sold to individuals looking to get free medical care. Of course, it really isn’t necessary when many could just go to an emergency room and get it anyway.
Cases are on the rise. I am very glad that I wasn’t one of those 250,000. People who work at medical offices are no more moral than people that do not. I do not trust the receptionist at the dentist office any more than I would trust a clerk at a convenience store. I don’t know them.
I think the main point not to be missed is that just because someone asks for your SS# does not mean that you should provide it. Now more than ever you need to limit access to that number as much as you are legally allowed to do. A medical clinic told me that anyone who worked at the clinic has access to my records. And I have found that to be true and had a big argument about that with an office manager a few years ago about it. Her answer was that it was “for my own good” and she couldn’t understand why I would object to anyone working at that clinic would have access to my information.
The bottom line is that at this time there is no good reason, unless you are using a government program to pay for medical care for these clinics to have this information and you are not legally required to give it to them. In that case why would you?
I had to provide mine in order to get the work financed by CareCredit (GE), which makes sense as for any kind of loan. P.S. I always pay these off before the 0% promotional period ends.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.