Since my salvation is not contingent on me believing one way or the other, I can wait for the answer.
I used to be pretty noncommittal about it, myself, but I did some reading, and a couple of very simple things stand out for me.
Jesus says in Matthew 19 that in the beginning God created them male and female, which of course reinforces Genesis and the story of creation. Evolution teaches that humans are a recent arrival on the stage. Either Jesus is lying, or evolution is wrong.
Also, according to the Bible, the world was without sin, suffering, or death until the fall of man. But evolution teaches eons of bloodshed and death before man ever showed up.