“It’s like you evaluating your doctor immediately after surgery, without knowing if the surgery was a success or not. The students simply lack proper information to do an analysis.”
Back when I was in Jr High we were asked to evaluate our teachers. I gave one teacher a scathing evaluation. I hated the guy.
About the time of my 50th birthday I realised that teacher I so hated was actually the best teacher I EVER had.
Practical experience and time had given me the wisdom to properly evaluate my teachers.
Yes, sometimes we really dislike exceptionally hard teachers, though my very best two teachers were the two in college I could NOT get an A from to save my life.
I went to a Catholic high school. For Geometry, to fill-in for a year, the admin. brought in a retired, very old religious brother who probably earned his collar teaching kids in the 1920s. He was very rigid, had a clear process and system for teaching geometry. His teaching style, I thought at the time, was a window to the past, and very unusual by the early 90s. But If you followed his methods, you learned geometry.
Of course, a few of the kids (who weren't good students anyway) told their mommies things like "he doesn't let us ask questions" or "his system is old-fashioned and stupid" and a few activist mothers got this man fired.
I still learned geometry, and of course, the kids who complained still wound up doing poorly.