Two Obscure Cases about Fish May Disempower Health Agencies

MEDPAGE TODAY ^ | February 10, 2024 | Suhasini Ravi, JD, MPH, Andrew Twinamatsiko, JD, and Lawrence O. Gostin

[gov_bean_ counter]

Sure, we all want to be ruled by agencies wo have agendas that have nothing to do with public health...

[RetiredTexasVet]

If the science is so great it would not be an inconvenience for them to present it to an actual judge and jury.

[curious7]

I not sure some of them could reliably deliver pizzas. Just sayin’

[LegendHasIt]

Fish?....

...Speaking of Fish: I’d rather have Detective Fish (Abe Vigoda) from the old Barney Miller show making the rules from federal agencies than these corrupt pseudo-scientists.

[SunkenCiv]

• Oregon officials confirm first bubonic plague case in the state since 2015 [02/12/2024]
• Oregon health officials confirm first human bubonic plague case since 2015 [02/11/2024]
• COVID Vaccine Injuries Deserve a Day in Court [02/12/2024]
• COVID Vaccine injured man confronts Prime Minister Sunak: "We're silenced" [02/12/2024]
• February 12 coronavirus news [02/12/2024]
• Telltale amino acid deficiencies may hold the key to new treatments for long COVID, say researchers [02/11/2024]
• Alaska confirms first fatal case of Alaskapox [02/11/2024]
• The Loss of Things I Took for Granted Ten years into my college teaching career, students stopped being able to read effectively [02/11/2024]
• The Meaning Behind "The Fightin' Side of Me" by Merle Haggard and Why the Hippies "Pissed" Him Off [02/12/2024]

[oldplayer]

Judges are not required to be scientists or doctors. They just have to be wise enough to determine what is reasonable.

This is what they do routinely. (If Trump’s damages to a woman he may have never met are worth 83 million, you have to question a judge’s wisdom, I know.) But, SCOTUS could certainly find it UNreasonable to require a mom and pops 3-man fishing boat to pay for a full-time ride along federal by-God inspector (who will be over-paid and “entitled to” a cushy retirement at age 45).

[sergeantdave]

Unelected fascist bureuacrats don’t like it when the doors to their Frankenstein labs are flung open for public view.

[Uncle Miltie]

“SCOTUS appears poised to substitute its judgment for that of career scientists”

Wrong.

SCOTUS may hold that Congress may not delegate lawmaking authority to unelected bureaucrats.

Get it right.

[subterfuge]

so something was opened in a new tab or window. Got it.

[Chuckster]

Too Pissed Off to compose an intelligble post on this.

See tagline.

[FreedomPoster]

Bingo! Great summary of what is really going on here.

[FreedomPoster]

Chicken tendies. Chicken tendies is what mommy brings these basement dwellers.

[rigelkentaurus]

No Federal agency of any kind should be able to issue rules, regulations, etc on their own. They should only be able to recommend them to Congress for creation into laws. Congress should not be able to delegate the creation of what is effectively laws to the bureaucracy.

[Eagles6]

"every American should want career professionals to issue rules that keep us healthy and safe, and that safeguard our environment."

😀😃😄😁😆😅🤣😂🤨🤢🤮

Umm...no...no, they shouldn't.