No. You have to first give a flip about what somebody thinks in order to put them on a list, "S" or otherwise. Even the hopelessly blind, tone-deaf, and moronic amongst us get to have their opinions.
The Beatles (John) said, Elvis was the one who figured in their musical style and 'he' was emulated in 'their' way.
Elvis was/is the man of his time. No doubt about it. He took songs performed /recorded by others and made them #1, or top ten, by his renditions. His gospel albums were huge sellers. He crossed barriers that others never tried or succeeded in doing.
Elvis was not able to cope with his fame and success. He went down to the basest weaknesses of his character.
Sad, indeed.
Yes, you had to be there.
This is like reading a review of Paul McCartney
by someone who didn't know he was in a
band before Wings. Get someone who's
been there to do the review. This is stupid.