Look, you're wrong. It's that simple. You must be a stranger to New York politics, particularly Giuliani's three NYC mayoral campaigns.
For that matter Giuliani is no champion of liberty either. In this part of the country he would qualify as a liberal Democrat.
Now, you're trying to have it both ways. "I'm right, and even if I'm wrong, I'm right."
Hayzeus! You NYC people are not only living in another dimension, but are too arrogant to admit reality. Try not to be insulted, because I don't mean this personally - in fact, I suspect you are NOT part of the majority, but when I lived there I noticed the same thing. Most people in NYC thought processes began and ended in NYC. They had the ability to totally deny reality. I remember having discussion vis a vie government, cops, taxes, gun control, etc. Facts and reality made no impression. I was told I was wrong to question their beliefs. No logic was given just as you give no logicical argument. It's just that my views were immediately dismissed as wrong, and I wasn't even as conservative then as I am now.
Just exactly what about my statement that Hitlery won because she got the majority of the votes do you disagree with? Let's go through the steps logically and clearly, and you tell me where it is is that NYC logic differs from the Aristotilian kind.
Now, you're trying to have it both ways
Nope not at all - part of the same thing that your lack of experience outside the Marxist environs of NYC makes it hard for you to see. The entire political spectrum of "conservative" to socialist in NY (and NJ, MA, CT, MD, RI, DC and DE too for that matter) is much farther to the left than in the real parts of the country. Take my word for it. You obviously haven't seen a real conservative politician, and living in NYC you never will. Yet still New Yorkers prefer the most left wing of the the left.
I further notice that you ignore my additional examples of how New Yorkers vote for the neo-Nazi freedom haters time after time. UpChuckie Schemer. Did he get elected because Giuliani had prostate cancer. Did Ranger, McCarthy, Owens, Nadler, etc. get elected because there was some flaw in their opponent's advertising campaign? No of course not. They were elected because the majority of New Yorkers are hard core envious cowardly socialists (and socialists are envious and cowardly by definition) who are afraid of freedom and envious of those of us who still have a little freedom left.