I was asking you a question. Based on your comments I couldn't tell whether you supported this plan, or merely thought it isn't as bad as represented on FR.
I apologize. I misunderstood your intent. My complaint was about all of the knee-jerking going on all over FR about this topic.
To answer your question, I'll refer you to george wythe's #26 in this thread, since he said it so much better than I could.