I doubt very seriously it was intended to serve as a template for immigration policy.
There's no fallacy, because I gave you the reasons conditions, perceptions and action would drastically change.
"Luke intended to dictate to believers what should be their personal policy towards the poor & less fortunate.
That's correct. Now your personal policy should be reflected on your lips and in your vote. Bush's proposal is to protect the right of opportunity and at the same time protect the nation from the disaster of uncontrolled criminals. It doesn't have to contain any giveaways of other people's money and it allows for many of the present giveaways to be ended. Charity is a voluntary thing. It is not charity when it's forced. Freedom of opportunity simply recognizes an individual right. The jobs are not unlimited. That limits the opportunity.