[Fishing-guy]

Boy, with this argument, Sadam was actually a good guy.

[blackdog]

Someone is going to shoot at a bus full of children on their way to school. You have seven guys in your jail who know where, when, who, and how. They refuse to cooperate and feed you false information regarding the whereabouts of the rest of their group.

Whatchya gonna do?

I think the 9/11 commission is asking one thing and demanding another, while hiding behind civility.

Let's study the Israeli's and their experience with Islamic prisoners? I'd love to hear some running history of the methods used in Israeli prisons. On the one hand I know they are good, compassionate people. On the other, they are constantly being attacked and gathering intel is vital. How do they walk that line? Do they?

What experience have the Russians had with prisoners from the Chechnyian conflict? Turkey? Greece? Spain? Indonesia?