Secondly, any advantage you imagine by having Guiliani on the ticket would be negated by people who would be antagonized and would not vote, including pro-life people and other conservatives who like Cheney.
Third, the changing of the ticket would cause demoralization, as it would be seen as a move made due to panic. Negative press would ensue, and we would have to hear about Guiliani's divorce all over again. His ex-wife would take to the television and radio with all sorts of gossip.
This is not a practical idea, and I want to win as much as you do. This won't do it, however.
regarding your points:
I discussed the first, Bush's personal loyalty, above. It is my view that Bush must rethink this; the moral imperative here is the greater, collective loyalty to the Constitution.
I referenced the second point when I stated that conservatives must look beyond the provincial in these lethally dangerous times. Will conservatives really consign their children's fate to a Pres. Kerry?
Third point: I suspect that changing the ticket would energize at least as many as it would demoralize.