The one problem with the theory is that as long as the 2nd Amendment exists, Muslims will not be able to 'doom' Jews here. One Jew with a gun in his hand is greater than 240 Muslims, armed or not. And given that there are about six million Jews in the US, there would need to be nearly a billion and a half Muslims here to give them a 50/50 chance at it.
While your point about the superiority of Jewish soldiers to Mohammedans is quite true, you are forgetting that the vast majority of American Jews are for abolishing the second amendment. JFPO is a brave group, but small. If leftists are able to end the RKBA, Muslims will go after Jews big time once they acheive sufficient numbers here.
but what invite that problem period? from what I have seen in the modern era, groups like the Cubans who embrace conservative values like appreciation of RKBA are the exception not the rule.
no offense but Jewish group behavior to me often appears collectively self destructive.
as a Goy, I'm not along for the ride....wish they'd listen and quit so frequently thinking of themselves separately and exclusively....thay are always welcome with my tribe should they decide to share my views on prevailing against the moon rock evil that is after us both.
frustrating.