Replies

Many of them are as nominal Christians as as are Jews…These nominal Christians are making common cause with Muslims. See the alliance between the Aztlandistas and the Muslims on the college campuses. Or see the proclivity of many new immigrants to ally with the Party of the Oppressed - the DemocRats…I'm in agreement with this writer. I see the immigration laws as currently promulgated as a threat to MY culture as a Christian…MY preference would be to limit immigration for a while to those strictly fleeing persecution for religious reasons. That would limit it to religious Christians and religious Jews…Flame away anyone and call me a bigot, but Muslims have an entire region to live where they are not oppressed, but are the oppressors…Christians and Jews in those regions are fleeing those oppressors. Plus, they tend to be conservative in their social outlook which suits me fine.

I agree with you. My point was that this isn’t a “Jewish” issue, rather a liberal vs conservative one. Aztlan is a perfect example, they’re rabidly anti-Semitic, have had decades long associations with Arafat, and they’re Christians (if they’re anything). The article makes some good points, but the titles are silly. The immigration issue isn’t about “Jews welcoming Muslims” or “Why Jews Welcome Muslims”, rather about liberals (most of whom aren’t Jewish) promoting open and even illegal immigration. And the threat of unassimilated immigration isn’t to Jews, as you note it’s to American culture. Defining the issue as why are the Jews letting the Muslims in completely misses the point.