Navy Veteran Van Odell Responds to Kerry

SBVT ^

[gilliam]

Statement by Navy Veteran Van Odell, Swift Boat Veterans for Truth, in Rebuttal to Michael Dobbs, Washington Post, August 19, 2004

A courageous, soft spoken man of the Midwest, Larry Thurlow has a heart bigger than the great plains and a commitment to truth and honesty that is boundless. He is under attack, because John Kerry is feeling the heat of truth at the hands of this honest man and others like him.

The Kerry Campaign is attacking the truthfulness of this man and the Bronze Star he so richly deserves for his actions on March 13, 1969. I was there. I saw what happened.

The mine’s detonation lifted PCF-3 completely out of the water just yards ahead of me. All boats commenced suppression fire in case enemy small arms fire ensued. None did.

All boats came to the aid of PCF-3, except one: John Kerry’s boat. Kerry fled.

Larry Thurlow piloted his boat straight toward the mine-damaged PCF-3 from which thick, black smoke billowed. He jumped aboard and personally led damage control operations that saved the boat and rescue operations that saved the lives of badly wounded men. Larry’s leadership was in the highest traditions of the naval service. His leadership allowed the other men and boats of the mission to exit the river safely.

This “single act of meritorious service” – the chief requirement of the Bronze Star – should be honored, not ridiculed, by the Kerry campaign and its allies in the mainstream media.

To reiterate, only one enemy weapon was deployed that day – the command-detonated submerged mine that disabled PCF-3. Larry Thurlow’s citation contained references to “enemy small arms and automatic weapons fire,” because that was the language chosen by John Kerry who penned the “spot report” on the action that day. There was no “enemy small arms and automatic weapons fire” received that day. John Kerry’s report was fiction – a hoax on the entire chain of command.

Larry Thurlow’s heroism and meritorious service, however, is real. To me Larry is one of the heroes of our country. He is a man who served his country when called and who returned home to be a productive citizen. Larry and men like him are the strong backbone of our society. I am proud to have served with him.

[EDINVA]

so now you know why Kennedy admires him so greatly ;)

[knick knack]

BUMP!BUMP!BUMP!BUMP!BUMP!BUMP!BUMP!BUMP!

[S.O.L.]

When swift boats encountered enemy fire did they routinely call for combat support (such as arty or air). If so would those units have after action reports for the Rassman rescue incident? If they normally call for support, but in this case there are no records for any such requests, does that imply there was no or insignificant enemy fire?

[S.O.L.]

Another point:

One of the major disputes is whether there was enemy fire during the time Kerry picked up Rassman and Thurlow brought the mine damaged PCF 3 under control.

The online version of Dobbs' Washington Post "Swift Boat Accounts Incomplete" articles includes a copy of the after action report. The last section describes the casualties.

Most of the casualties described seem to be of the type caused by the mine explosion rather than by intense, heavy automatic and small arms fire from both shores.

I served with the First of the Ninth Air Cav (the chopper unit depicted in 'Apocalypse Now'). If there was heavy enemy fire against sitting ducks (boats) in the water, there would have been more and different types of wounds than those described.

The Viet Cong were not such bad shots as to miss that many times during a two hour rescue attempt. So either those Swifties were the luckiest bunch alive, or the fire was not so intense.