Free speech means that the individual has the final say of what he or she says. Just as an individual cannot be silenced, so too can they not be compelled to speak against their will.
And aside from Constitutional issues, compelling loyaltly oaths to the state reeks of totalitarianism and is an affront to liberty in general.
Exactly!!
Yep, paying respect to the nation you live in is one step away from Nazi Germany. Totalitarianism, by cracky.
You're absurd. The schools are compelled to direc the pledge and anthem, but the students aren't compelled to participate. You have to make a pledge to become a citizen, to qualify for a government job, to join the military, etc.