Posted on 08/31/2004 7:11:48 AM PDT by ZGuy
If Bill Clinton was the first black President -- a moniker he relished -- then George W. Bush is the first Jewish President. After first disengaging from the Israeli-Palestinian peace negotiations and refusing to even lay eyes on Yasser Arafat, Bush went on to give Israeli Prime Minister and best Mideast buddy Ariel Sharon virtual carte blanche in his crackdown on the suicide-bombing Palestinans and then followed the advice of his fiercely pro-Israel neocon advisers and went to war in Iraq.
Matthew Brooks, executive director of the Republican Jewish Coalition, calls Bush "the most pro-Israel President in history." And on the Republican Jewish Coalition Web site, former New York Mayor Ed Koch, a Democrat, writes that he's voting for a Republican for President for the first time in his life because "George W. Bush has amazed me. Bush 41, the father, was not particularly good on (the Israel) issue. I do not believe he was anti-Semitic but his Secretary of State, James Baker, perhaps summed up the attitude prevailing in that Administration when he said, 'F--- the Jews. They don't vote for us anyway.'"
Now the FBI is investigating whether a Pentagon official in the office of neocon Defense Under Secretary Douglas J. Feith, identified by The Washington Post as Lawrence A. Franklin, passed classified information about American policy toward Iran to Israel through a pro-Israel lobbying group. The obvious question about the probe, which has been reportedly going on for a year but was first reported by CBS last week, is this: As details come out, will Bush's tilt toward Israel hurt him in November? The less obvious question is: Will the scandal help him even more with some Jewish voters?
"ONE OF US." Certainly the Administration isn't downplaying the vigorous support of the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, the lobbying group implicated in the spy scandal. At a pre-convention event on Sunday afternoon co-sponsored by AIPAC (which vehemently denies allegations that it passed sensitive documents to Israel) and attended by almost 2,000 members of the New York Jewish community, the Republicans rolled out the big guns: Mayor Michael Bloomberg, Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist, and former Mayor Rudy Giuliani. UJA Federation of New York President Morris W. Offit introduced Bush campaign chief Ken Mehlman by saying: "We are honored that President Bush's campaign is being managed by one of us."
Almost since Inauguration Day 2001, Bush has been a lot like a kid with a piggy bank. He has been putting in a few pennies worth of backing here, a dime's worth of support there, and hoping that on Election Day when he busts the ceramic porker open, he'll have just enough new voters behind him to buy four more years.
This strategy of political incrementalism has been pursued almost religiously (but, hey, what hasn't been?) by the White House. That's why Bush comes across as an 18-year-old on Levitra with his wooing of the American Jewish community. So with 63 days to go before Election Day -- to paraphrase a famous Ed Koch line-- "How's he doin'?"
IN THEIR HANDS? Before the spy probe broke in the papers, some of the answers were on a yacht-for-rent bobbing in the Hudson at the Chelsea Piers dock on the night of Aug. 26. That's where The Israel Project, a two-year-old nonprofit devoted to promoting a positive image of Israel in America, was holding the first of several events scheduled for Republican Convention week.
Between bites of sushi, Brooks of the Republican Jewish Coalition delivered the partisan answer, predicting that Bush would do substantially better than the 19% of the Jewish vote that he captured in 2000. The surprise, he says, is that "the President is going to do particularly well among seniors because they are much more Israel-centric" than younger Jewish voters. In the swing state of Florida (where Jews account for around 5% of the electorate), if enough older and traditionally Democratic voters cross over to Bush, he muses, "the Jewish community could very well decide the election."
A less biased answer to how Bush is doing is given by David Borowich, the 34-year-old chief operating officer of tech startup Optinetix. "The Jewish community had very low expectations of Bush...but I think he has delivered for America and for the Jewish people," says Borowich, who has dual Israeli and American citizenship. But, while he thinks either Bush or Kerry would be acceptable, Borowich says a lot of Jewish Americans are asking themselves: "Why have we always been voting Democratic?"
GUT FEELINGS. The leader of a leading nonpartisan Jewish-American umbrella organization, who declines to be identified, says while it's a mistake to look at the Jewish vote as even close to monolithic, in broad terms, American Jews divide up between those for whom the security of Israel is of primary concern and those for whom social issues such abortion and stem-cell research are paramount. And, as for every American, he adds, economic performance is an overarching issue.
This wise man's assessment is that while he sees Bush as "a simple man without a great intellect," he believes the President has a visceral feeling about the need to protect Israel. And he says, as the country as whole has become more conservative, so have Jews. His Aug. 26 "snapshot" is that on Election Day in November, the Jewish electorate will split 75%-25% between John Kerry and Bush, with Bush getting a maximum of 30%.
That assessment is at odds slightly but significantly with a poll conducted in July by Greenberg Quinlan Rosner Research for the National Jewish Democratic Council and The Solomon Project: It found likely Jewish voters choosing Kerry over Bush by 75%-22%.
Still, it's a problem for Kerry if the wise man's hunch is closer to reality and a larger-than-expected number of Jewish voters go for Bush.
The reason only just now occurred to me. (Duh!)
That voting block is one of the wierdest things. You really have to know a few Jews to understand just how much unlike the Jews in the bible they are.
Ahhh... the Old Zionist World Government Conspiracy again...
This sort of crap deserves to be tossed out.
its in the genes. Most people vote the way their parents did, including bringing their parents' politics over the ocean with them.
There is a split among Jews.
The Orthodox always tended to vote for W because they share the same family values.
There are 9/10 Jews who don't really care about Israel because they are Americans. They do fear the "religious right" more than they fear Islam. Unless they are themselves bombed, they will never vote for a pubbie.
Finally, there are 9/11 Jews who understand the danger that confronts the country in general and them as Jews in particular. They know who Leon Klinghoffer (sp?) was and who killed him. They don't need Rudy Giuliani to remind them.
The 9/11 Jews understand that without personal security, there can be no real freedom. They are lock-solid behind W.
Dennis Prager, the talk-radio host, and an observant Jew, says that the "religion" of most US Jews is liberal politics.
Mind detailing this a bit further? I'm curious.
In the minds of a lot of 'liberaloid' Jews, FDR is still alive and the New Deal rescued them from poverty. If they'd think for a moment they would face a huge cognative dissonance re the Jews, Israel and the world in general.
75% - 22% AGAINST President Bush. How disgraceful...
That's a sad situation.
One very tiny example, the 15 yearold new Jew friend of my son came over to our house for some D&D. Now this kid is a very bright kid and constantly talks about being a Jew, no pork, except for things he likes ofcourse, learning yiddish, got a bah mitsvah(sp) etc etc. When I mentioned anything at all about Moses he had no response, no knowledge no nothing. To Jews in the bible Moses was an absolute hero. This kid barely knew the name.
Bush will do very well with Jewish voters. He'll get 40% or more of the Jewish vote.
Last month we hastily organized a last minute FREEP of a Bush-Bashing Rallt hosted by the evil Jan Schakowsky. We had about half a dozen FReepers show up and we were jopined by two yamulka-wearing guys who said they were representing "Orthodox Jews for Bush." They surely made a welcome addition to our group.
When I mentioned anything at all about Moses he had no response, no knowledge no nothing.
Interesting. The boy knows he has some rules to follow, but apparently no knowledge of biblical history. That is abnormal - if a Jewish child is sent to Hebrew School, which is very common, he knows ALL about Moses, Abraham, Isaac, etc. However, this child apparently doesn't. This is a common theme in the Jews that you know? May I ask how many you know?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.