That's a robotic response, and you failed to refute his position.
I think Dobbs is exactly correct on this.
So Ok we should keep jobs that went to indians anyways. Fine, nonody will argue the fact that outsourcing sucks, but its a two way street. Protectionism at home will invaritably result in protectionism against us. Which means companies like Toyota and Honda wont build plants or other companies wont invest here because of rules setup to punish America for protectionism.